What Makes Beth’s Dead So Hard to Stop Listening To
Beth’s Dead podcast is a limited true crime series from Armchair Expert’s Monica Padman, made in collaboration with Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen of Nobody’s Listening, Right?
The show started when Padman finally asked her favorite podcasters why they abruptly shut down their old show years earlier, and the answer turned into a real investigation into what happens when a parasocial relationship goes terribly wrong.
Here is a look at the ten episodes that trace this story from a simple dinner conversation to a genuinely shocking conclusion.
10 Beth’s Dead Podcast Episodes With the Most Chilling Stories
1. You Took Something Away From Me
Monica asks Elizabeth and Andy why they really ended their old podcast, setting the stage for a story so unsettling that she knew it had to become a show of its own.
2. You May Recognize My Vagina
Elizabeth, Andy, and Monica look back on their years of interacting with listeners, and one particular fan starts to stand out from the rest in ways that feel increasingly hard to explain away.
3. I’m Begging You
As the details of the story deepen, the tone shifts from strange to genuinely alarming, with Elizabeth and Andy recounting just how far this listener relationship had gone.
4. Were You Her Therapist
Monica listens as Elizabeth and Andy relive the exact moment they realized what they thought they knew about this listener, known as Beth, was nowhere close to the whole truth.
5. The Questions Keep Multiplying
With more information coming to light, Monica steps fully into investigator mode, and the mystery only gets more complicated the closer she gets to answers.
6. We’re In A Little Bit Over Our Head
The trio confronts just how deep this investigation has actually pulled them in, questioning whether they are equipped to handle what they might find next.
7. The Confrontation Begins
This installment pushes the investigation toward a confrontation, as Monica, Elizabeth, and Andy prepare to face the person they believe is behind everything.
8. Deep Breath, Deep Breath
Monica, Elizabeth, and Andy reach out to the one person they swore they would never want to speak to again, in one of the season’s most tense episodes.
9. Can You See Me Now
The true identity behind the deception finally comes into focus, revealing a twist that upends everything the trio thought they understood about who Beth really was.
10. One Year Later
Closing out the season, Monica, Elizabeth, and Andy reflect on making the podcast and how a simple dinner conversation turned into a story none of them could have predicted.
Why These Episodes Stand Out
Each entry on this list reflects a different stage of how the story builds. The early episodes plant genuine unease around a listener relationship that feels slightly off, the middle stretch turns into a real investigation led by Monica, and the final episodes deliver both a stunning reveal and a reflective close.
That structure is a big part of what makes the series work as a complete season rather than a loose collection of episodes.
How to Start Listening to Beth’s Dead in 2026
All ten episodes are available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and Amazon Music, with an ad-free version of the full series available through Patreon.com/BethsDead.
Since the story builds chronologically and leans on unfolding twists, starting with episode one is the best way to experience it as intended.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Beth’s Dead Based On A True Story
Yes. The series follows the real experience of podcasters Elizabeth Laime and Andy Rosen, investigated by Armchair Expert’s Monica Padman.
How Many Episodes Does Beth’s Dead Have
The core story runs across ten episodes, with additional bonus episodes answering listener questions available through Patreon.
Where Can I Listen To Beth’s Dead
The show is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, and ad-free through Patreon.com/BethsDead.
Final Thoughts
Beth’s Dead turned an offhand dinner conversation into a genuinely chilling investigation into how far a parasocial relationship can go, told by the very people who lived through it.
From the early unease of You May Recognize My Vagina to the reveal in Can You See Me Now, these ten episodes offer a complete and unsettling season to work through in 2026.
